Being a seasoned traveller, I like to share my experiences on these types of Forums (TripAdvisor, etc) because people need some help (including myself) navigating the myriad of choices available. I will start with this:
"Read between the lines"
Someone elses experience or expectations are probably not the same or similar to your own, that's why I recommend checking different types of reviews (good & bad) and various sites for a better rounded review. Some people are easy to please and others are not!!!