Had a family cruise... with 7 cabins. Do not recommend Select Dining... especially for a medium size group. (We had 14 people). First day or so had issues with seating and getting reservations at 7PM. After this was settled, the overall cruise quality was fine.
Have seen some comments regarding food quality. Found the variety and quality was fine... Only went to buffets for breakfast and lunch... Did not got to Qsine, but some of our party did, and they were pleased.
Dining staff was very accomodating to one person in our party who had a severe food allergy. Gave him the next days menu, and he was able to order a day in advance, with the kitchen knowledgeable about the allergy.
We had outside cabins on deck 2, midship. First time cruising on that low of a deck... but a very different perspective in looking out the window almost at water level. Also being midship, this is the cabin area with the least amount of movement. For a cruise like Bermuda.. where we have all seen water before... a good value. Only negative... more engine noise than on higher decks... but very acceptable.