We have now done 3 Cruises on 3 different Cruise Lines, we are not loyal to any one line and always look for the best overall Deal. So with that in mind I will do a Comparison of our 3 Cruises.
2012 Holland America Zuderdum Alsaka
2013 Carnival Spirit South Pacific
Shower is very small, when the sofa bed is pulled out there is no room to step around it you have to step over it, noise was not an issue, it is above the Pub/Casino on deck 6 , but did not here any noise. The lifeboats are on the deck below and there is a roof/cover over the top of them so you can see directly below but the view from the balcony is fine, it also has a slightly bigger balcony as it wraps around a bend