The Liberty is a fine ship I have been on 8 different ships and I found the Liberty to be clean and well laid out. The new 2.0 upgrades were nice . I HATE THE NO SMOKING POLICIES I get a balcony just so I can smoke and now that has been taken away. This will be the single biggest reason I do not book a future cruise. I am already booked on the Sunshine in late February in an aft cabin. I like being in the back of the boat. It is a short walk to late night pizza. We ate at the steakhouse on the first night at sea and it was awesome. The food, service and presentation was top notch. There was not much in the way of entertainment as far as shows go which was a problem. the serenity adult deck was nice but it was hard to get a chair there some days. Guys Burger Joint was GREAT. I loved that place. All said I felt I got a great vacation.