We are experienced cruisers and have sailed on several ships and several different lines in the US and Europe. The following is my observation.
Lines. Wait. Crowds. Reservations for a tender?
First the good. The food was as good or better than most ships (once you obtained it).
Too small. Poorly lit. Oddly configured.
Nice place - not much to do.
Shopping or take ferry to a different island.
Still dumpy after all these years. Where is all the tourist money going?