We are veteran cruisers who were just looking for a quick getaway over Easter. While we were a little apprehensive [Easter break = lots of kids!], it turned out to be a great weekend.
Looking for quiet? It is possible. We spent mornings and afternoons up on Serenity on the couches in the shade. It was quiet and peaceful, great for reading and napping. Even though the stairs to the slide were right outside the entrance, the slatted barricade blunted the noise to the point that we were seldom aware.
Dining room - We thought the food was excellent and our servers were outstanding [shout out to Alexander, Lincoln and Unting!]. They were helpful, efficient and fun to be with. I sent back one entree and it was promptly replaced with an alternative that was delicious.