• Write a Review
  • Boards
  • Log In

2019 Cruisers' Choice Destination Awards

View top-rated cruise destinations and lines around the globe according to cruisers, based on member review ratings for trips taken in the last year.

Top-Rated Cruise Line Private Island Destinations

Castaway Cay

1 of 5 Cruise Line Private Island Destinations

Photo by Cruise Critic member KKMMex

"[Castaway Cay] is still the best place on earth. Plenty to do for all ages. More than enough room for all to spread out so it seems very peaceful and tranquil. "

Member Review: Flake0911


Find a Cruise to Castaway Cay
Castaway Cay Port Reviews
Castaway Cay Shore Excursions

Labadee

2 of 5 Cruise Line Private Island Destinations

Photo by Cruise Critic member Allasher

"Wow! What a spectacular view when floating in the water. The mountains in the background made this the most beautiful beach I’ve ever been to."

Member Review: Meznics

Half Moon Cay

3 of 5 Cruise Line Private Island Destinations

Photo by Cruise Critic member zlqzcc

"Half Moon Cay is a beautiful little island. The beach is immaculate, the water was warm, and the seas were calm."

Member Review: WScruiser

Amber Cove (Puerto Plata)

4 of 5 Cruise Line Private Island Destinations

Photo by Cruise Critic member Hrgail

Harvest Caye

5 of 5 Cruise Line Private Island Destinations

Photo by Cruise Critic member amccosh

"Loved this place. The beaches were great. The pools were fabulous. Lots of chairs for everyone. People were very nice and friendly. The wildlife and butterfly exhibit were beautiful! The entire island was beautiful!"

Member Review: PATMILLER


View More Cruisers' Choice Destination Awards

Overall Cruise Destinations

Alaska Destinations

Asia Destinations

Australia & New Zealand Destinations

Baltic & Scandinavia Destinations

British Isles & Western Europe Destinations

Cruise Line Private Island Destinations

Eastern Caribbean, Bahamas & Bermuda Destinations

Eastern Mediterranean Destinations

European River Destinations

Hawaii Destinations

Mexican Riviera Destinations

Panama Canal & Central America Destinations

South America & Antarctica Destinations

South Pacific Destinations

Southern Caribbean Destinations

US & Canada Destinations

Western Caribbean & Riviera Maya Destinations

Western Mediterranean Destinations


See More Cruise Critic Awards

UK Editors' Picks Awards

See the lines and ships that best represent excellence in ocean, river and luxury cruising, chosen by Cruise Critic's international team of editors.

UK Cruisers' Choice Awards

Get to know the best cruise ships in a variety of categories, based on member review ratings for cruises taken in the last year.

Want to cruise smarter?
Get expert advice, insider tips and more.
By proceeding, you agree to Cruise Critic’s Privacy Policy and Terms of Use.
Cookie Consent