We just returned from our family cruise this week on the Disney Magic. Adding insult to injury, I was informed by one of Disney's staff members that this is the last trip for the Disney Magic until it gets entirely rebuilt and modernized.
We spent a week on the Disney Fantasy voyage to the Caribbean in December and found the quality of the food and facilities to be superior to any other cruise line. The Disney Magic is a much older boat, and this trip did not live up to our expectations for Disney.
-Palo Restaurant was excellent in both boats