We chose this cruise because some we knew others who were going to be on the Eclipse. We had a great time, the weather was good and the Atlantic was very calm, maybe 5-6 foot waves at most for the whole cruise. This cruise gave us the chance to catch up with friends and spent time together, especially during sea days. Disembarking at the various ports went smoothly. Even though the ship appeared fully booked for the most part you didn't feel that it was too crowded, except occasionally in the Oceanview. Rooms and common areas were very clean, food was generally very good and the entertainment that we attended was good, especially Jayne Curry, she was amazing and very funny! Our butler and room attendant were awesome and willing to go the extra step to make us happy. I think that cruises are what you make of them - if you're determined to have a good time you will. All in all a great time!
Cabin was spacious and very clean, however, we did get noise from the deck above, especially first thing in the morning. Only annoying aspect of the whole trip.