My wife an I did this cruise a few years back with a couple of friends - it was a great experience so we thought we should do it again with some other friends.
Now we were impacted by the Hurricane, but not as baldy as the cruise just before us. That cannot be helped and I have no complaints about that - though 6 weeks to get a refund is pretty slack - only takes minutes to accept your money!
My main gripe is that there is very little value for money, especially if you want to have a few drinks - diet cola costs $5... A 6 pack of beer is $50! That is just extortion, on to which they add a 20% gratuity...
Just ok - clever use of space was good so we stored everything away. Did not notice much difference after the multi million $ upgrade a few years back
Hired a car and took off for the day - Hanalei bay was awful die to the run off, but had good swims at Poipu Beach and Waimea Canyon was awesome