Took my parents on this cruise for their 50th anniversary. There were 7 of us in total ranging in age from 21-78.
THE GOOD: Food was very good, and we liked Taste/Savor. Avoid the Manhattan restaurant unless you like very loud live music throughout your entire dinner. My Mother had to leave because she couldn't take it (though she's 77, it bothered all of us too). The Choir of Man show was really fun. The drink package, for $250 was well worth it - Bombay, Kettle One, Tito's are included. The private island was nice. Snorke/Sail in the Bahamas was nice as well.
THE BAD: I found the staff to be cold and unfriendly. The 80's show (Brat Pack) was just awful. A lot of people walked out. It was also difficult to get into most of the shows that wouldn't accept reservations beforehand. There are simply too many people for too few seats and shows. Be prepared to take the stairs a lot - elevators were usually packed. Again, too many people.
It was fine. Nothing remarkable or notable. Breakfast on the balcony was perfect for two.