We recommend Curacao. It had great beaches, clear water, warm water and the temperature was not too hot during our cruise.
St. Thomas and St. Martin were still recovering from hurricane damage but our beach excursions were nice.
We enjoyed the onboard shows and recommend them.
We were very happy with our cabin attendant. My wife liked the towel animals she made. The cabin did not have easily accessible electric plug sites for our CPAP machines. Fortunately we had a long extension cord to reach the single plug.
The tour was interesting to see some of the local sites. We enjoyed the beach as well.
We greatly enjoyed the beach and water of Curacao. There was a very good Crepe shop on the beach as well.
This island was still recovering from the hurricane. We enjoyed the beach.